Repetition has always been part ofAssassin’s Creed; even fan-favorite games follow similar patterns. The first game was known for its repetitive missions,Brotherhoodhad players climbing tower after tower, andBlack Flaghad endless tailing sequences; the open-world RPG entries get even more criticism for their copy-paste side content.
As the worlds got bigger, the problem only grew. A huge map might seem exciting, but when the activities start feeling the same, it can turn into a chore. Clearing out forts, syncing viewpoints, and collecting scattered items can feel more like busywork than adventure. Even with great stories and fun combat, the series has struggled to keep things fresh. That’s whyAssassin’s Creed Shadowsstands out. While the series has always leaned on familiar gameplay loops, this game might finally have a way to make things feel less repetitive.
Quick Links
Every Assassin’s Creed Game Has Some Repetition
AllAssassin’s Creedgames have relied on repetitive gameplay. The first game was packed with the same few mission types. Follow a target, eavesdrop on a conversation, pickpocket some information, and repeat. It set the foundation for the series, but by the end, many players felt like they were just going through the motions.
Assassin’s Creed Shadows Main Story Quest Walkthrough
Like most RPGs, Assassin’s Creed Shadows is divided up into quests. Here’s how to complete each one of them, with additional resources for some.
Later games improved on the variety, but the problem never disappeared.Brotherhoodintroduced a more open Rome, but a big part of the game was climbing towers to claim new areas.Black Flaghad its thrilling naval combat, but the sheer number of tailing missions dragged it down. Even some of the most beloved entries, likeAssassin’s Creed II, had their share of repetitive tasks.
Despite their repetitiveness,Brotherhood, Black Flag,andAssassin’s Creed IIall did well in sales.Brotherhoodis actually considered one of the greatest video games of all time and won multiple awards, and shipped 7.2 million copies from its release date of 2010 to May 2011. Black Flagis anotherwell-received Assassin’s Creed gameand was one of 2013’s best-selling games.
The open-world RPG era only made things worse. WithOrigins, Odyssey,andValhalla,Ubisoft went bigger than ever. The worlds were massive, but they were filled with activities that often felt copy-pasted. Forts, camps, and enemy outposts all started blending together. Instead of carefully designed challenges, players were given huge checklists to complete.
A massive map is exciting at first, but if the content inside it feels samey, it becomes predictable. Players want exploration to feel rewarding, not like a to-do list.Assassin’s Creedhas struggled to find that balance, butShadowsis on the right path.
That’s not to say the games weren’t fun. The combat improved, the stories got deeper, and the settings were stunning. Still, the sense of discovery started to fade when each new location felt like a slightly different version of the last. The problem isn’t just the size of the world, it’s how that space is used. A massive map is exciting at first, but if the content inside it feels samey, it becomes predictable. Players want exploration to feel rewarding, not like a to-do list.Assassin’s Creedhas struggled to find that balance, butShadowsis on the right path.
Assassin’s Creed Shadows Makes Stealth Dynamic
Shadows' Stealth Makes The Game More Engaging
Assassin’s Creed Shadowsbrings back a real focus on stealth. In past games, sneaking around was often an option but not the main way to play.Shadowschanges that by making stealth feel more natural and important.
Assassin’s Creed Shadowsis the newest AC installment, taking place in feudal Japan. It has had generally positive reviews from critics, and hassurpassed previous installments like Valhallaand Origins in number of Steam players.
One big change is how light and shadow affect gameplay. Staying hidden isn’t just about breaking line of sight. Darkness helps players stay out of sight,but light sources can change that fast. If a sudden light source appears or the sun rises, hiding spots disappear. Players have to stay alert and adjust.
Weather also plays a role. Rain makes footsteps quieter, while mud slows movement. These small details make sneaking around feel realistic and different each time. Instead of just memorizing enemy patrols, players have to react to the world around them. Smalldetails of blood and mud appear on a characterwhen interacting with the environment, making the game feel more realistic, too.
Lastly,Shadowshas two playable characters, each with their own style. Yasuke is a strong warrior who can use stealth but is better in combat. Naoe, a shinobi, is quick and quiet, making sneaky approaches feel more rewarding. With these new mechanics, stealth feels more exciting and useful. Instead of being just another option, it’s the heart of the game.
Stealth Can Help Fix The Open-World Assassin’s Creed Problem
Shadows' Stealth Is Something All AC Games Should Learn From
Older games likeBlack FlagandBrotherhoodhad great settings but often leaned on repetitive side content.Other games, likeMirageandUnity,excelled at stealth and parkour, which made the games feel more dynamic and engaging.Miragehad well-designed stealth encounters, whileUnity’sparkour system let players navigate the world in creative ways.
All The Assassin’s Creed Games, Ranked Worst To Best
The Assassin’s Creed series currently has 20 games including spin-offs and handheld releases - here’s how they all stack up compared to one another.
Scaling down the world a bit could also help. Instead of filling a massive map with copy-paste objectives,futureAssassin’s Creedgames could focus on detailed, handcrafted locations. With better level design and deeper stealth mechanics, missions would feel more engaging.
Bringing back classic features like social stealth is another smart move. In earlyAssassin’s Creedgames,blending into crowds added depth to missions. It makes exploration feel more natural instead of like just another task list.
Stealth-focused gameplay naturally creates more variety. It forces players to adapt, experiment, and come up with creative solutions.Assassin’s Creed Shadowshas started to lean into that type of gameplay, but futureAssassin’s Creedgames could fine-tune it. It could finally break the cycle of repetitive open-world content that has plagued the last so manyACgames.
