Below Deck Sailing Yachtseason 5 has brought its usual mix of engaging charters and crew tensions, but a rumored love triangle between Daisy Kelliher, Gary, King, and Keith Allen couldruin Daisy and Gary’s friendship. The first half of the season has given viewers significant crew changes and a fiery personality clash involving Chef Cloyce Martin with other crew members. These challenges have only amplified the crew’s tendency to make mistakes, leading to consequences that risk the passengers' safety aboard. However, these events kept fans tuning in for more drama, and the mid-season trailer seems to promise a love affair.
BDSYmasterfully blends working tensions with personal problems,creating a reality TV cocktail that keeps fans returning season after season.Daisy and Gary’s relationship is either having a playful, friendly conversation or engaged in a fiery argument, all while having undeniable chemistry. Now rumors are running wild, with the whisper of a new love triangle brewing in the second part of the season. Fans cannot help but wonder if this season’s drama can finally push their relationship to a breaking point. As fans gear up for the second half of the season, all eyes are on the unfolding tensions.

The Complicated History Of Daisy & Gary’s Dynamic
A Friendship That Keeps Fans Guessing
Daisy and Gary’s relationship onBelow Deck Sailing Yachtseason 5is filled with many ups and downs. From the moment Daisy joined the crew as Chief Stew during season 2, her relationship with First Mate Gary has been a focal point ofBelow Deck Sailing Yacht.They have built a complex friendship that feels genuinely authenticand unscripted—qualities reality TV shows fans crave and have been lacking from theBelow Deckfranchise. Their relationship ebbs and flows, and depending on the day, they constantly swivel between friends and foes, creating drama that is much needed forBDSY.
20 Best Reality TV Shows Right Now
Reality TV is more popular than ever. With so many to choose from, here are some of the best reality TV shows to stream or watch right now.
Their close bond often invites speculation among fans as well. The pair have shared, over multiple seasons, many flirtatious interludes, and who could forget their infamous hot tub kiss?Some root for a romantic turn and others prefer their relationship to remain platonic. However, despite their intense disagreements, they always return to the balance of a friendship. This evolving and devolving bond has become a cornerstone of the series' emotional appeal.

A New Cast Member Shakes Things Up
When New Faces Bring New Drama
As the crew prepares for another charter season,rumors are swirling about Deckhand Keith Allendisrupting their already shaky relationships. Rumors suggest Keith might become a third point in a love triangle involving Daisy and Gary. If this happens, the stage is set for some of the show’s most intense relationship drama yet.
This isn’t Gary’s first time navigating turbulent waters in the romance department. Gary’s romantic history onBelow Deck Sailing Yachthas already shown his knack for stirring the pot. From his season 2entanglement with Sydney Zarubaand Alli Dore to the unresolved tension with Daisy in subsequent seasons,Gary’s love life has often been a lightning rod for conflict.

This new potential love triangle might also bring fresh challenges to the crews' already shaky ability to work together cohesively. Even though the crew is no stranger to navigating personal conflicts while maintaining their professional responsibilities,adding another layer of romantic tension might test their limits.One more spark onboard could lead to an explosion no one is prepared for.
What Does This Mean For Daisy & Gary’s Friendship?
The Challenge Of Navigating Romantic Waters
For Daisy and Gary, the implications of a love triangle extend beyond romantic drama—it could threaten the core of their friendship. If jealousy takes hold, the duo may find it challenging to maintain the trust that’s been their anchor in previous seasons. Creating a second love triangle could upset the work the two have already done.
Romantic entanglements have consistently fueled the drama onBelow Deck Sailing Yacht, with two notable relationships standing out. DuringBDSYseason 1, Paget Berry and Ciara Dugganworked on the yacht as a couple.They faced the challenge of balancing their professional and personal livesonboard the yacht in a way that other relationships have not had to face. Their dynamic also provided a keen perspective on maintaining a relationship in high-pressure environments.

Below Deck Sailing Yacht Season 5’s Attempts To Recreate The Gary-Daisy-Colin Love Triangle Won’t Work (It Won’t Be As Dramatic As The Original)
Below Deck Sailing Yacht season 5’s attempts to recreate the magic of its season 4 love triangle won’t work, as things will never be as dramatic.
During season 2, Gary and Alli shared a brief but intense romance.Their situationship unfolded amid tension with another crew member, Sydney, who also had feelings for Gary. Their love triangle led to several emotional confrontations, keeping viewers on the edge of their seats, wondering what would happen next.

Nonetheless, Daisy and Gary have weathered their fair share of conflicts, yet they’ve consistently demonstrated an ability to reconcile and move forward, often emerging stronger than ever.Love triangles often add excitement to a season but can strain existing relationships.For Daisy and Gary, Daisy falling for Keith could lead to emotional tension and challenges. Could the pressure finally push them to confront any underlying feelings they’ve avoided? Or will the drama force them to redefine their relationship altogether—whether as friends, coworkers, or something more?
Social Media Sets Sail With Theories
Anchoring The Drama
As fans digest the rumors, social media has become a hotbed of speculation. Many are rallying for Daisy and Gary to finally become a couple, while skeptics voice concerns that adding romantic tension could jeopardize their cherished friendship.Some predict explosive confrontations and emotional fallout,while others hope for a slower, more nuanced exploration of the trio’s relationships.Overflowing Shelfwrites, in part on Threads, “The romance fan in me has been shipping Daisy/Gary forever, and I want them together.” And on X@its1stclassCAMwrites, “i’m here for daisy and keith being a boatmance. as long as it’s not gary.”
Comment sections are flooded with theories about everything from Keith’s background to how he’ll navigate the love triangle.Viewers have come to expect a level of unpredictabilityfromBelow Deck Sailing Yacht, and the buzz around the potential love triangle has only heightened anticipation for the upcoming season. AsBelow Deck Sailing Yachtsails into the second half of its fifth season, the stakes for Daisy and Gary’s friendship have never been higher. Introducing a new love triangle promises to shake up the dynamics, but whether it brings Daisy and Gary closer together or drives them apart remains to be seen.
Will this season finally reveal the true nature of their bond? Or will the turbulence of romance at sea prove too much for even the strongest of friendships? Fans will have to tune in to find out—but one thing is certain: the drama will be worth the wait. Let the speculation begin!
Below Deck Sailing Yachtairs Mondays at 9 p.m. EST on Bravo.
Below Deck Sailing Yacht
Cast
Below Deck Sailing Yacht is a spin-off of the Below Deck reality television series. Premiering on Bravo, the show follows the life of a Yacht crew as they attempt to navigate a busy Charter season in which many customers make use of a 177-foot sailing yacht. Over the first three seasons, the yacht has been to Greece, Croatia, and Spain.